Atonement + The Piano

Double feature: Some witnesses to an event never testify, but rather take the evidence they see under their own advisement and immediately reach their own verdicts, mete out their own justice.

In the case of both “Atonement” and “The Piano,”
*these witnesses are young girls,
*the events they observe and interpret (from the remove of a windowpane) involve furtive dealings between one of their close female relatives and a man with a tangential relationship to their household, *and the justice they deal with their own hands has consequences beyond the grasp of their comprehension.

Whether the events they witness are equally beyond their comprehension is up for debate.  In both films, the girls’ reactions are complex enough to make us question whether they stem from innocent lack of understanding or an intuitive grasp of the situation’s implications and a willful rebellion against them.  Fear, bi-directional jealousy, and some kind of excitement are mixed in as well, and activate preservation instincts in the girls that are more animalistic than rational.

With this shared plot point, both films illustrate the degree to which an event – or a relationship – and its interpretation by outside parties diverge into separate trajectories.

For a marathon: “Atonement” likely borrowed much of its clenched atmosphere from repeated viewings of “Brief Encounter,” another WWII-set film.

Like “The Piano,” “Jane Eyre” and “A Dangerous Method” offer glimpses of insight into the psychological drawing-out of women who, to varying degrees, have retreated into themselves.

Two Terrence Malick films – “The Thin Red Line” and “The New World” – share “The Piano”’s exploration of the wondrous and volatile encounter between two vastly different cultures.

(Creative Commons licensed original images courtesy of “Sifu Renka” and “net_efekt” at Flickr)

2 thoughts on “Atonement + The Piano

  1. This kind of case can extend to ambiguity of love relations.Like in films Camille or Notorious,both female leading role did not realize the man she loved also loved her,and both suffered a lot from their own judgement.

Add another film connection or comment:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s